Dragons in Dungeons? Myths of Imprisonment From Cultures Without Prisons
Dragons in Dungeons? Myths of Imprisonment From Cultures Without Prisons
ABSTRACT
This article explores 14 myths from seven cultural contexts in which imprisonment was not an established institution of criminal justice, but which nevertheless feature the use of practices resembling contemporary imprisonment. Approaching these myths as literary narratives that can be understood as a species of speculative fiction, the study identifies three themes in the uses to which such myths put imprisonment: revenge upon the prisoner, constraint of a threat, and exploitation of a useful resource. It concludes by identifying two meta-narratives about how myths of imprisonment treat prisoners themselves, arguing that the extent to which the audience is expected to feel solidarity with the prisoner influences the sense of justice in that imprisonment. From this, it follows that advocates for penal reform or abolition aiming to limit the use of imprisonment must consider how to promote solidarity between prisoners and the audiences of their activism.
David J. Hayes